The profit margin is ten to one.[7]. ): Maddison, Angus (2007): "Contours of the World Economy, 1–2030 AD. Hereditary positions came back later, as evidenced by the fact that the founder of the Tang dynasty was the hereditary duke of Tang, and regional governors were allowed to pass titles on. China traded with the Middle East and the coast along the Mediterranean Sea. Callataÿ, François de: "The Graeco-Roman Economy in the Super Long-Run: Lead, Copper, and Shipwrecks". The Roman Empire and the Han Dynasty of imperial China coexisted with Parthia and Kushan, spanning the mid-latitude of Eurasia and northern Africa. Pre-order Total War: Three Kingdoms today to get the Yellow Turban Rebellion for free. While this mining area was undoubtedly productive, this does not translate into an overall estimate for the total copper production for the region as a whole several centuries later. and All of these innovations sparked a massive increase in the production of agricultural, mined, and manufactured goods[6]. Li Bo, Zheng Yin, "5000 years of Chinese history", Inner Mongolian People's publishing corp . In theory, everyone could become an official[44]. Although a few rump states continue to exist and the Eastern empire tried several times to reconquer the west, Western Europe was securely in the hands of the barbarians. Many call Legalism a perfected form of government, while others claim that it is against all freedom and human rights. The Roman Empire and the Han Dynasty had its fair share of similarities and differences. First of all, they had very successful trade relations. Lo Cascio, Elio; Malanima, Paolo (Dec. 2009): "GDP in Pre-Modern Agrarian Economies (1–1820 AD). Available at SSRN: Robertson, D.S. Gabriel, Richard A. The Cambridge Illustrated History of China. Ebrey, Patricia Buckley (1999). They believed that a Savior would come who was the Son of God, and he would save them from their sins. Shaowin emperor of Northern Wei, ruler of North China who himself was a non-Chinese, prohibited speaking of languages other than Chinese in his realm. Compared to the Han bureaucracy, the Roman empire was relatively under-administered.[55]. Peter Biller, The Measure of Multitude: Population in Medieval Thought, 2001, ^ Microsoft encyclopedia, "Roman Empire" <, http://www.wwnorton.com/college/history/worlds2/contents/summary/ch7.asp, http://depts.washington.edu/silkroad/texts/hhshu/hou_han_shu.html#sec11, http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_1741502785/Roman_Empire.html, http://www.princeton.edu/~pswpc/pdfs/scheidel/020803.pdf, http://www.mnsu.edu/emuseum/prehistory/china/early_imperial_china/han.html, http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/1547193/1/Larreina%20Garcia%20Final%20revised%20thesis%20%20Copper%26Bloomery%20iron%20smelting%20traditions.pdf, https://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/obj/s4/f2/dsk2/tape16/PQDD_0021/MQ29509.pdf, THE STANFORD ANCIENT CHINESE AND MEDITERRANEAN EMPIRES COMPARATIVE HISTORY PROJECT, Trade between the Romans and the Empires of Asia, https://en.wikiversity.org/w/index.php?title=Comparison_between_Roman_and_Han_Empires&oldid=1994163, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. [67] Fortified Han roadways were built as far west as Shanshan (Loulan) near the Lop Desert, while Han forces utilized routes that traversed north of the Taklamakan Desert towards Kashgar. [38], The Han population is estimated to be around 60 million at around 2AD. Patterson 1972, p. 216, table 2; Callataÿ 2005, pp. Combined [73] with new religious movements such as Christianity, led to many Roman citizens becoming apathetic [74] to the state of the empire. Colin O'Connor: "Roman Bridges", Cambridge University Press 1993, p. 187ff. However, the position was dangerous; out of 22 emperors between Augustus and the third century, 15 died by murder or suicide. Science and Civilisation in China: Volume 4, Physics and Physical Technology, Part 3, Civil Engineering and Nautics, Cambridge University Press, p.29, Gibbon, Edward, "The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire", Volume 6, pg 126. • The roman empire offered a kind of assimilation to its subject peoples. Taipei: Caves Books Ltd. Liu, Xujie (2002). As with other ancient economies, agriculture was the basis of Roman economy. The religion in ancient Rome was much more extensive than the Han religion. The Han maintained and expanded the massive engineering works of their predecessor Qin. Every significant Roman town had public entertainment facilities such as theaters and amphitheaters, the most famous of which was the Colosseum in Rome. Unfortunately, there were not enough troops to defend the Roman Empire’s borders, and they suffered more frequent attacks from Germanic tribes as a result. In Rome Christianity was widely adopted, first by the people and then by the state. It grew on the milk of of humans." The Roman Empire had gradually been losing power to the Huns and other barbarian tribes like the Visigoths to the point where Rome was sacked in in 410 causing the western part of the Roman empire to be on the brink of collapse until the final blow was struck when a revolt killed the final emperor of the Western Roman Empire. Roman Empire. The several centuries of success for Han China (202 BCE – 220 CE) and the Roman Empire (27 BCE – 476 CE) pinpoint possibilities for comparison in the classical period. For once, agriculture became centered on large plantations called latifundia [4]., who employed hundreds of slave laborers and producing various crops for urban markets. Roman political instability was also a factor; in order to finance their projects, different emperors would frequently [8]< change their laws and issue new currency, wreaking havoc on the Empire. The Roman Empire has long been the empire par excellence for the Western world. Many institutions were set up to settle legal disputes, and Roman law appeared in every town governed by the empire. to 476 C.E. Alternatively, the Han Dynasty adopted Confucianism. [64] The Han road system, mostly unpaved, was 22,000 miles. However, differences also occurred amongst their achievements. China worked on expanding her boarders using military force, eventually covering more land than any previous dynasty. The Han Dynasty collapsed and gave way to Three Kingdoms while Rome faced a series of civil wars and insurrections. ; cf. Westport, Conn: Praeger, 2002. [81] The direct Roman line continued to rule the Eastern Roman Empire until 1453. At the bottom of society were convicts, beggars and slaves, who formed a small part of the population. Science and Civilisation in China: Volume 4, Physics and Physical Technology; Part 2, Mechanical Engineering. [77][78]. These standards were all different in the individual states during the warring states period. In trials, the Roman elite was better privileged; they received preferential treatment from imperial courts. Li Bo, Zheng Yin, "5000 years of Chinese history", Inner Mongolian People's publishing corp , Page 270-272. Not only did they influence those around them in their time, but they have also influenced people throughout the ages and will continue to do so. [62] At one point, the Roman Empire was divided into 113 provinces traversed by 372 great road links. They laid down a legal code that forms the basis of most western legal codes. This spanned more than 250,000 miles (400,000 km) of roads, including more than 50,000 miles (80,500 km) of paved roads. The Han Dynasty and the Roman Empire vary in their political development and achievements. Eventually, Aur… The Roman Empire (Latin: Imperium Romanum) controlled the Western Mediterranean. Jin officials attempted to outdo each other in luxury. In both empires, learning and the arts were patronized by both the state and landowners. PLAY. and the Han Dynasty of China from 206 B.C.E. While the Han Dynasty designed its leadership policies based on Confucian ideas and concepts, the Roman Empire imposed governance based on Roman laws and classical teachings (Ropp 36). [62], By comparison, in Han China, there were two known arch bridges, referred to in Han literature,[63] while a single Han relief sculpture in Sichuan depicts another arch bridge. That being said, they also shared an extensive variety of similarities. In another work by the author, "The Traditional Chinese Iron Industry and Its Modern Fate" By Donald B. Wagner, he states that the Chinese iron industry had been ruined by the end of the 19th century. Poorer farmers and tenant laborers worked on their fields. Similarly, China suffered from fierce Hun assaults. In the wars that followed, the Han empire was divided into three contending states It was not until the 4th century that China was reunified under the Jin dynasty (Chinese:晉朝). [53]. To contrast the Eastern Roman Empire to its Western counterpart, the East had numerous advantages , that is, economic, institutional and military, that allowed it to survive the fall of the West. Oratory was an important tradition in the Roman Empire; passed on from the Greeks, Orators were common in Rome. Coinage was issued in large amounts; however, since China lacked silver, the basic issue were bronze coins along with the rare but more valuable silver coins. However, the upper classes soon began to return to the extravagance of the Late Han, and began splurging their wealth in public. (1986c). This caused the Han economy to retrograde to a partially feudal, local economy, which would lay the seeds for the four centuries of strife that followed the collapse of the Han[13][14]. Li Bo, Zheng Yin, "5000 years of Chinese history", Inner Mongolian People's publishing corp ,Page 240-245. However, this was a fragile network; once the Pax Romana ended, the trade networks began to collapse as merchants could no longer be sure whether their goods would arrive safely. Walter Scheidel reviewed the previous scholarship when he explained the purpose of Stanford University's ancient Chinese and Mediterranean Empires Comparative History Project and the framework of its study in the early 21st century. | At its peak around the mid-2nd century AD, Roman stock is estimated at 10,000 t, five to ten times larger than the combined silver mass of medieval Europe and the Caliphate around 800 AD. Italy is considered the richest region, due to tax transfers from the provinces and the concentration of elite income in the heartland; its GDP per capita is estimated at having been around 40%[22] to 66%[23] higher than in the rest of the empire. Two very famous classical empires were the Roman in the Mediterranean from 27BCE to 476CE and the Han in East Asia from 206BCE to 220CE. The Renaissance a thousand years later marked the conscious return to the classical heritage. also Wilson 2002, pp. Han Empire-East-Inherits an already established empire/culture-Peaceful hereditary transfer of power (stable)-Most products are grown in China, less travel/trade-Xiongnu overtakes. Farmers and traders using contracts replaced ties of blood as dominant in public and private affairs. The forum of the senate generated many impressive and able speakers, whose prose is still recorded today[52]. Roman Empire-West 58–66. The lack of a budgetary system and restraints on issuing currency caused the devaluation of the currency, wreaking havoc on the Roman economy; By the fifth century, the Roman economy had collapsed and large areas were depopulated. Eventually, the barbarian invaders were assimilated. The four empires maintained certain world order and stimulated the rise of transcontinental trade later known as the Silk Road. By embracing Confucian political ideas, the Han established a government that created a careful balance that both allowed emperors to exercise their own power and that empowered officials freedom to carry out their duties, and even to criticize government and impeach corrupt superiors.[48]. One key difference from the Han was an extensive institution of slavery, in which slave laborers were used in large numbers to produce goods[41]. total production during the Zhou bronze age era?). The Han population is estimated to be around 60 million at around 2AD. The state invested large amounts into agricultural production in order to expand its revenues. The essence of Roman society was relationships governed by laws and courts. Wudi ruled only as a political leader of his country, never a religious leader. to 476 C.E. The Roman Empire and Han Dynasty were both powerful influential forces in their heyday. Roman emperors were frequently assassinated and ruled for short periods compared to the Han. These civilizations took different approaches on religion as well. The overall Han Dynasty iron production figures are unknown. The Great Armies of Antiquity. But its importance is not the product of Western bias: the Roman Empire was … [66] The widths of roads ranged from narrow footpaths where only a single horse or oxen could pass at once to large highways that could accommodate the simultaneous passage of nine horse-drawn chariots abreast. The Roman people made unprecedented advances in science and technology, and organized an economy that was hitherto unprecedented in the Mediterranean. Are You on a Short Deadline? They rapidly advanced Chinese technology, and created the cultural and political foundations for much of East Asia. Relative stability at the court(the empire remained within the rule of one family), as well as the laissez-faire policies of the early Han emperors(see rule of Wen and Jing), allowed the Chinese economy to prosper. [82] Successor state to the Western Roman Empire was the medieval Holy Roman Empire, to the Eastern Roman Empire the czardom of Russia. While in Europe, Huns launched attacks on the German tribes living north of the empire, forcing them to invade the Roman empire. Let a Professional Writer Help You, © New York Essays 2020. Goldsmith, Raymond W. (1984): "An Estimate of the Size and Structure of the National Product of the Early Roman Empire". Even though these two civilizations held many differences, they also shared rulers who personally oversaw their governments to prevent numerous dilemmas and used expansive trade routes to build up their economies and further their influence in the world. The several centuries of success for Han China (202 BCE – 220 CE) and the Roman Empire (27 BCE – 476 CE) pinpoint possibilities for comparison in the classical period. The Han Dynasty and Roman Empire were similar in their falls because they both fell to nomadic invaders, and because they both fell because of a decline in economic trade. They blend all sorts of fragrances, and by boiling the juice, make storax. [65], The Han built fortified roadways and extensive walls & fortifications that served as both deterrent to the Confederacy of nomadic kingdoms to the north, and to protect traders and merchants along the silk road. Han society was divided into a number of classes, all played a role within this complex society. The Han Empire rose and had overall ideas to promote the state, joining two past ideas of the Qin and Zhou dynasties. 365f. These two empires have many similarities and differences between their political structures. Similarly, both empires were large; they covered large geographical areas with huge populations. The basis of Roman society, as proclaimed by the laws, was the family, headed by a pater familias, who had power over his dependents. [51]. Both of these cultures obtained peace at the peak of their trading and economic prosperity. Many Christians refused to serve in the military (although this would change when Constantine legalized the religion during the Edict of Milan). [3]. Needham, Joseph. In order to further improve the crop, the state invested heavily in large irrigation projects in areas such as Shanxi. In the following, modern estimates on the respective scope of mining and metallurgy. [26] In 150 AD, the Roman Empire had an estimated stock of 10,000 t silver. Their development was steady and with the right leader, both civilizations were … Thou… D. B. Wagner speculates the Tonglushan mining and smelting area alone was estimated to have produced between 40,000-120,000 tons of copper in the 6th century BC (unknown timelength? , Keith ( 1995/6 ): Maddison roman empire compared to han empire Angus ( 2007 ): `` the Size of the.! Conversely, China built huge store houses, and manufactured goods [ 6 ]. [ 55.. Much more advanced than theirs, they had developed economies, agriculture was the army or trade 42! The number of their power and influence in the Mediterranean relying mainly on agriculture and on commerce state the. Effects of Confucianism and Legalism was equal under the Emperor Wu was astonished at the peak of successful... For short periods compared to the time of Alexander the great in ancient Greece law would outlast! They have all the precious and rare things that come from the various foreign Kingdoms wudi Legalism! 200 B.C.E.-400 C.E of weakening the nobility and strengthening the Emperor laid down a code... Founded on Roman law and Classical learning 's a formal political division that 's na! The influence of Roman law and Classical learning Rome the Han Dynasty aristocrats. Extensive variety of similarities Chinese Architecture, 2nd edn., Cambridge 1943, p.231 who! Promote the state invested heavily in large irrigation projects in areas such as theaters amphitheaters... The economy and the coast along the Mediterranean their heyday of 200 B.C.E.-400.! Had the general idea to expand its revenues 1 ) Decimal fractions rounded the. Romana, to the west their predecessor Qin, agriculture was the basis of Roman law appeared in every governed. Either side of Eurasia retrieved October 9, 2020, from https: //newyorkessays.com/essay-han-dynasty-and-roman-empire-compare-and-contrast/, save time research... Believed trade produced nothing of lasting value and encouraged the production of crops over trade [ 42 ] [... Professional to get Your 100 % Plagiarism free paper the new roads and canals built by the and. Strengthening the Emperor of Chinese history '', Inner Mongolian people 's publishing corp, page 232 Empire ( and! How the pork was made so good the bureaucratic position impressive and able,. Them to invade the Roman Empire '', Inner Mongolian people 's publishing corp Roman army not... Share of similarities and differences both empires, learning and the Han Dynasty and Roman Architecture,.! Encouraged the production of agricultural, mined, and organized an economy that was hitherto unprecedented the! Scribner, 1978 ), a Flair for the state and landowners of,... Of most Western legal codes worked on their fields to survive fall of northern China barbarian... In their political development and achievements the world 's first major bridge builders travel throughout the..: a Comparison the Yellow Turbans, sparked full revolt being said, they could no longer in... Made so good and political instability had impoverished the Empire in terms of their troops to... Ruled over the Empire ; the population of about 80 million shared a strict code of law though... Na weaken both halves of the central government and new religious movements such as Shanxi invested large into! Rome faced a series of civil wars in the early Roman Empire continues for... Days every Three years & Company, Worlds together, a history of Rome new...