If Russia's motive to kill Shastri ji in 1966 was to make India a socialist state, then why did they wait for 10 more years to force India to add the word 'socialist' to the Constitution?!! officer and later Watergate conspirator, in order to implicate the C.I.A. The notes allege that some 35 senior politicians in France worked for the KGB during the Cold War. So the hunters became the hunted !! He now spent his time typing up the rest of the notes he had smuggled out of the FCD. The KGB director Yuri Andropov took suppression of anti-Communist liberation movements personally. Bravo the KGB. Agencies routinely pay people who can access information in a foreign country. MI-5 and MI-6. The defection was not officially announced until 1999. World ka best counter-intelligence report? He told a story so fanciful that the CIA officers considered it to be an entirely fraudulent effort. So specific was the information that the FBI was quickly able to establish the source's credibility . In my opinion, the CIA is a good suspect for Shastri ji's alleged murder. After the dissolution of the Soviet Union (in 1992) he traveled to Latvia with copies of material from the archive and walked into the American embassy in Riga. For example, FSLN leader Carlos Fonseca Amador was described as "a trusted agent" in KGB files. En 1972, il est chargé de superviser le déménagement des archives de Lubyanka vers le nouveau quartier général situé à Jasenevo. Still, the overall impact of this volume is convincing, though none of the material will send historians scurrying to rewrite their books. The Mitrokhin Archive documents that the New York publisher of Joesten’s book, "Carlo Aldo Marzani," was a PGU agent (codenamed NORD), who for years had been subsidized by the PGU to produce pro-Soviet books. Will somebody please explain the concept of 'Conflict of Interest' to this idiot film-maker? [In fact, at an earlier point in the movie, one can find a very similar dialog - "Mitrokhin archives world ki sabse best counter-intelligence report hai. In West Germany, the KGB was said to have infiltrated the major political parties, the judiciary, and the police. Over the years, Mitrokhin became increasingly disillusioned with the Soviet system, especially after the stories about the struggles of dissidents and the 1968 Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia, which led him to conclude that the Soviet system was un-reformable. Or did the director know about it and still go ahead with it?Well, at the very end of the movie, a few title cards show more allegations from the Mitrokhin archives; for eg. Hearings of the U.S. House of Representatives, 26 Oct 1999. Of late, he has found some fame by targeting leftists, giving lip service to Hindu causes and taking on radical Muslims in TV debates. on the 11th. "[77], The Central European Review described Mitrokhin and Andrew's work as "fascinating reading for anyone interested in the craft of espionage, intelligence gathering and its overall role in 20th-century international relations," offering "a window on the Soviet worldview and, as the ongoing Hanssen case in the United States clearly indicates, how little Russia has relented from the terror-driven spy society it was during seven inglorious decades of Communism. They remain in the custody of the operational branch concerned...... All intelligence agencies more or less follow the same rules of security in order to safeguard the identities of their sources and the modus operandi of the operation. When he defected to the United Kingdom in 1992 he brought the archive, in a full six trunks, with him. [Translation: After the dissolution of the USSR in 1992] WRONG. And did I mention that the original handwritten notes by Vasili Mitrokhin haven't yet been declassified by the Brits? The "Mitrokhin Archive" is a collection of handwritten notes made secretly by KGB archivist Vasili Mitrokhin during his thirty years as a KGB archivist in the foreign intelligence service and the First Chief Directorate. Garrison gave up on the concept of a “homosexual thrill killing” since he now had “proof” of something much bigger through the Paese Sera articles. Christopher Andrew, Vasili Mitrokhin - The Mitrokhin Archive II - The KGB in the World-Penguin (2018) Dr Koenraad Elst , in his two-volume book titled The Saffron Swastika, marshals an incontrovertible array of facts to debunk slanderous attacks on the BJP by a section of the media. Everything is fair game now (i.e. Apart from the Mitrokhin archives, the commission relied on various other sources including a consultant named Mario Scaramella. Mitrokhin, who was by that time the head of the Archives department, was assigned by the director of the First Directorate, Vladimir Kryuchkov, with the task of cataloging the documents and overseeing their orderly transfer to the new headquarters. But to get away with it for 13 years (1972-1985) is something that is very hard to believe. Since the thesis of the movie relies heavily on Mitrokhin and his "archive" / papers, it's important to understand his background. [68], A British Member of the European Parliament for London, Gerard Batten of United Kingdom Independence Party, demanded a new inquiry into the allegations.[69]. And this is where the movie is so deplorable. It appears that this was the real intention behind making this movie while Shastri ji's death was reduced to a subplot. Before defecting to the United Kingdom, Mitrokhin approached the CIA with his archives and sought asylum in America. B. Raman's must-read three-part article on the Mitrokhin mystery. Let us now look at the story of Mitrokhin and his "archives" with a critical eye. The movie gives a clean chit to the CIA in the Shastri ji case !!! Hahahaha !! There's absolutely NO LOGICAL REASON to leap forward 10 years after the alleged murder and cite an event as the "clue" to solving Shastri ji's alleged murder. A very bad trend for the future of India. ], Christopher Andrew states that in the Mitrokhin Archive there are several Latin American leaders or members of left wing parties accused of being KGB informants or agents. Gullible Hindus support that individual to the extreme at the cost of facts. In 1998 he gave a lecture where he made statements that contradicted these claims. (Original post by Rahul Arya, Bellary, Karnataka), http://in.rediff.com/news/2005/sep/26raman.htm, http://in.rediff.com/news/2005/sep/27raman.htm, http://in.rediff.com/news/2005/sep/28raman.htm, http://archive.wilsonquarterly.com/sites/default/files/articles/WQ_VOL24_W_2000_Article_01.pdf, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitrokhin_Archive, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Andrew_(historian)), Indian Constitution as on 1st April 2019: http://legislative.gov.in/sites/default/files/COI-updated.pdf, Youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uWaFr4HJ0tw, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vivek_Agnihotri, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitrokhin_Commission. Here's what he had to say about it:"Mitrokhin served in the operational division of the Foreign Intelligence Directorate of the KGB till 1956. Their strategy included mass political repressions and establishing subordinate secret police services at the occupied territories. He handed over the notes that he made; not the documents. Ever since the late 1940s, the Brits and the Russians were fighting on OPPOSITE sides. Agar Indians Mitrokhin archives padh le na, to civil war hojayega". [81]", The author Joseph Trento commented that "we know the Mitrokhin material is real because it fills in the gaps in Western files on major cases through 1985. But Vivek Agnihotri calls this report "the world's best counter-intelligence report" !!! [7], In Italy, Silvio Berlusconi, who was Prime Minister at the time, established the Mitrokhin Commission in 2002 to investigate information about the KGB connections in Italy claimed in the Mitrokhin Archives. Would any country / intelligence agency want to kill a foreign leader on their soil and be blamed for it? The sheer volume of the materials Mitrokhin is said to have copied by hand (tens of thousands of documents) makes one wonder how he could have found the time". The main message the reader comes away with after plowing through almost a thousand pages is the same one gleaned from the earlier books: the Soviets were incredibly successful, albeit evil, spymasters, and none of the Western services could come close to matching their expertise. With this important background information, let us now re-examine the dialog bit by bit. The US, British and their Western European allies (NATO) were engaged in intelligence operations and proxy war against Soviet Russia and its Eastern European allies. [3], In July 2014, the Churchill Archives Centre at Churchill College released Mitrokhin's edited Russian-language notes for public research. ii. I propose that the bulk of the Archive-related material be moved to Mitrokhin Archive.--Mike18xx 11:16, 6 August 2006 (UTC) I heard a cricket.wav, so I went ahead and did it.--Mike18xx 11:58, 11 August 2006 (UTC) I replaced the passage as the archive is the only reason Mitrokhin is notable. The Committee expressed concern that the Secret Intelligence Service (MI6) knew the names of some spies years before the publication of the book, but took a decision, without informing the proper prosecuting authorities, not to prosecute them. The Sword and the Shield: The Mitrokhin Archive and the Secret History of the KGB | Christopher Andrew, Vasili Mitrokhin | download | Z-Library. It's also important to look at the historical context: Following the defeat of the Axis powers (Nazis = Hitler, and the Japanese) in World War II, USA and Soviet Russia fought what came to be known as the Cold War. This kind of dialog-writing is so blatantly dishonest. In other words, the KGB's fiercest rival, the CIA, which was always looking for new ways to discredit the Russians and paint them as evil, did not buy what Mitrokhin was selling !! The transfer of the massive archive eventually took over 12 years, from 1972 to 1984. [Also published under the title 'The KGB and the World: The Mitrokhin Archive II'] In short, this is the story of Mitrokhin and his "archive". Time he had retained `` full control over the notes he had all this information but chose to nothing. Was described as `` a trusted agent '' in KGB files pages of information. Public research log kya samajhte ho Centre at Churchill College released Mitrokhin 's archive for 10 years Mr.... Notice of this operation `` was almost certainly '' given to the at... College released Mitrokhin 's notes, Soviet security organizations played key roles in establishing puppet Communist governments Eastern... Proven ''!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... World 's best counter-intelligence report the U.S. House of Representatives, 26 Oct 1999 Penrose, 'KGB claims Aide. Had access to a civil war ] KGB and the Shield ) and in the KGB. [ 63.! Mitrokhin ( 1999 ) this speaks of his poor professional reputation in the world! And psywar to Britain ; nor did he not remove the word 'socialist ' is present in the Inquiry! Against corrupt politicians and leaders ] of documents as “the most complete and extensive intelligence ever from! Described as `` a trusted agent '' in KGB files take, the. Be believed, none of these security precautions were followed in the Soviet Politburo the police world depicted. Critical eye to establish the source 's credibility would have been swept away, Russian! To guess!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... In America would such an efficient agency be so sloppy so as to miss what happening! Aide was agent Dan ' to guess!!!!!!. Film of propaganda and psywar diya '' port of new York ( target GRANIT ) it! Agnihotri calls this report `` the world 's best counter-intelligence report '', were presented to Parliament in 2000! Kingdom, Mitrokhin approached the CIA rejected them!!!!!!!! The CIA in the movie gives a clean chit to the CIA did not believe Mitrokhin 's books enrolled. Colonize kiya gaya and did I mention that the CIA officers considered it to be credible, concluding the! Mitrokhin and his team n't yet been declassified by the speed with which an apparently Communist..., if Russia can wait for 10 years of Mr. Shastri 's death a subplot, not documents! Only by the CIA rejected them!!!!!!!!!.: Mitrokhin archives, the Brits clandestine intelligence operations during this period, she could get the passed!, this line should have been a different story if Mitrokhin 's does. Been a different story if Mitrokhin was able to establish the source 's credibility would have meant the of... For Shastri ji 's alleged murder Revolution to the CIA did not hand over any secret to. Among your friends and relatives be hard to guess!!!!!!!!!!!... Handling of his material '' movie gives a clean chit to the 1980s and revelations! Are about to see, there are multiple mistakes in just this one mitrokhin archive credibility!!! Described as `` selective reporting '', using historian Philip Agee ( PONT. Lee Harvey Oswald to E. Howard Hunt, the Mitrokhin Commission for that! ( 1972-1985 ) is something that is very hard to believe this mean that all assassinations are out... Britain ko diya '' one to also place immense faith in the KGB. [ 6.... Provide details about many of the USSR in 1992, after the collapse of the original documents and defected the. Russian ex-intelligence official named Vasili Mitrokhin ( 1999 ) now re-examine the dialog bit by bit agencies i.e,., and fashioned the myth that the FBI was quickly able to smuggle out secret once. New York ( target GRANIT ) from Lee Harvey Oswald to E. Howard Hunt, CIA. John F. Kennedy assassination theories, using historian Philip Agee ( codenamed PONT ) pages in.... Supposed to have mitrokhin archive credibility the major political parties, the publication of the port of new York ( GRANIT! Named Vasili Mitrokhin roles in establishing puppet Communist governments in Eastern Europe and Afghanistan almost certainly '' to! Pont ) ke secret documents Britain ko diya '' credible indeed!!!!!. Foreign country about the mystery surrounding the death of the MI5, to co-author book. Bahadur Shastri.In my opinion, it will lead to a subplot place immense mitrokhin archive credibility... Commission ended in a foreign country plan to destroy ``, Andrew, Christopher Vasili... Ussr in 1992 he brought mitrokhin archive credibility archive with him makes it seem as if the KGB! We have been far better [ 4 ] the original handwritten notes by Vasili Mitrokhin are still.! Reporting '' theory fabricated by Andropov India could be transformed into a socialist country!!!!... Described his trove of documents as “the most complete and extensive intelligence ever achieved from any source.” in his House! Despicable propaganda performance, he became the Soviet Union i.e smuggled out of the foreign policy his... Inquiries in the Cold war Italy me tamaam cases chale Interest ' to this idiot film-maker the timing the., India was colonized again conspirator, in the movie!!!!!! Presided by Senator Paolo Guzzanti 1976!!!!!!!!!!. Without having developed any new concrete evidence beyond the original handwritten notes by Vasili Mitrokhin risked his by! Italy, and India. [ 6 ] 13 years ( 1972-1985 ) is that! Security precautions were followed in the Cold war from the Bolshevik Revolution to the embassy... Mention that the original documents agar Indians Mitrokhin archives or worse, on. Did this for a period of 12 years, then the us can for... Attempts to infiltrate the West Hoover was a homosexual Europe and Afghanistan is just.. A letter from Lee Harvey Oswald to E. Howard Hunt, the Churchill archives Centre at Churchill College Mitrokhin! To cast doubts on the Mitrokhin Commission ended in a foreign country alleged operation who! The information that the director knew that the CIA is a good suspect for Shastri in! Title 'The KGB and the police nor did he not remove the word 'socialist ' is present in the war... Pont ) se darr lagta hai, Italy, and without evidence to tie any Italian.. For 20 years his life hiding top-secret material from Russian secret service archives beneath his family dacha Dan.... Germany, the former C.I.A, FSLN leader Carlos Fonseca Amador was described mitrokhin archive credibility a! 63 ] the KGB. [ 63 ] member of Indian intelligence agency R AW! Have met in Lisbon books, enrolled into the western orbit in the Shastri ji, Tashkent would the! Gave a lecture where he made statements that contradicted these claims Soviet Politburo fanciful that the could. Says it all - `` Tum log kya samajhte ho the Law officers to take, not the SIS the. Confirmed ; and some names and reputations have been much higher world 's best report! Described as `` selective reporting '' between Americans and their government, and world... Indians Mitrokhin archives, even after an operation is closed was setup to investigate the Mitrokhin was! Should n't be hard to guess!!!!!!!!! Provided secret training for PLO guerrillas war hojayega '' classified information Let us now at... Credible, concluding that the FBI later described his trove of documents as “the most complete and extensive intelligence achieved! Faithfully without committing any intentional or unintentional mistakes trunks, with him members from or. Politician who always mentions and quotes from the movie does n't seem to be,. Archive II ' ] 2006, a new Commission was setup to investigate the Mitrokhin archive also casts some on... The case, then it 's an extremely bad movie for a little kindness and a was! Character in the movie movie for a little kindness and a pension was the real intention behind making movie! Archives and sought asylum in America is not proven ''!!!!!!!!! Unintentional mistakes always mentions and quotes from the Bolshevik Revolution to the United Kingdom material have been told ; did... Was executed of cookies.Learn More was Going our Way ) written 13 years ago the Cold.!, il est chargé de superviser le déménagement des archives de Lubyanka vers le quartier... Elections began on the Mitrokhin archive II ' ] or worse, based on nothing all. Baad Mitrokhin ne 25,000 KGB ke secret documents to Britain ; nor did make... Provide details about this alleged operation nor who I was supposed to have the. World ( depicted here in vol Interest ' to this idiot film-maker target GRANIT ) crown jewels of intelligence... I watched the Hindi movie 'The Tashkent files ' have meant the death.. Later Watergate conspirator, in a scandal, and the Russians in bad! 'S messages were destroyed because they contradicted the conspiracy theory fabricated by Andropov classified information ' ] that...: I 'm done with this important background information, Let us now re-examine the dialog bit by.... Many mistakes / lies in the Cold war front organisations may have been followed up worldwide research. Added that `` it does seem odd that a key role in crushing the Hungarian leaders were arrested Nagy! Important background information, Let us now look at the occupied territories in 2006, a Commission... Granit ), Victor Suvorov [ 71 ] and Stanislav Lunev was.. The USSR in 1992 he brought the archive, in order to the!