Let’s do things a little differently. I have heard I should be looking at glocks, but I found the Sig P229 more comfortable in my hand and actually revolvers even a bit more. Models basically the same size, like the P226 and P229 can feel very different in your hands. soon to be going to P320 9mil. That’s what’s so different this time. Forget all the math, I say buy whatever makes you happy! I have been racking my brain for couple of days now whether I chose a P226 or a P229. But we also know that a shorter grip won’t print easily, so guns with shorter grips will be easier to carry concealed. The current SIG Sauer cataloglists 10 variations of the basic P229. P229's can use preban P226 and P228 Magazines, so the Sig can easily be a full capacity pistol. The prices can be high, although some deals can be had. Glad you liked this article. We’ll not be including the .357 SIG this time because its recoil velocities are pretty much the same as the .40 S&W’s. That was a mistake. That is quite a bit of felt recoil. You browse through SIG Sauer’s website and find out that the P226 has a smaller compact brother (technically, “compact” in these contexts is incorrect — it’s supposed to be labeled “mid-size”) called the P229. Both have practically the same frame dimensions, the same exact magazine capacity, the same frame and slide material, the same SA/DA trigger pull weight, and the same number of rifling grooves and rifling length of twist. For me personally, I just don’t see the point in getting the full-size P226 when the mid-size P229 does everything it can do, is relatively easier to conceal, has the same mag capacity and costs the exact same $$$. Looking to buying my first pistol and this answered a lot of the questions I had. If we compare recoil velocities between a SIG P229 chambered for the .40 S&W (17.29 fps) and the same SIG P229 chambered for the 9mm (14.32 fps), the difference is ~17.17% in recoil velocity. We’ll get more into this later. The heavier a bullet and the more powder charge used to send it flying at higher velocities, the more the gun recoils. A couple of years later, the .357 SIG caliber round was invented and released with an updated model of the P229 that came with the .357 SIG barrel. We get a difference of ~28.68% in recoil velocities. There are a few ways to help your wife with recoil. Glad I could help. For .40 S&W, the force of the recoil from shooting the .40 S&W will send the SIG P226 flying 14.88 feet in a second, and the same force will send the SIG P229 flying 17.29 feet in a second, again a ~13.9% difference in recoil velocity. There is no such things as a preban magazine for a M&P. The P226 is an awesome shooter and using Mec-gar 18 rd. So if you’re wondering whether you should get a P226 or a P229 as a CCW for self defense (in whichever of the three handgun calibers available that you prefer), chances are the P229 will be the better option for you. Archived. Both are practically the same pistols chambered for the .40 S&W. The force of the recoil from shooting the 9mm will send the SIG P226 flying 12.33 feet in a second. The P228 is plenty strong for the 9mm, but newer calibers were being introduced, such as the .40 S&W and the .357 Sig, which operate with higher pressures. She was wondering about the 229 because of the praises she has heard about it. Specs on the standard model follow: In addition to a choice of three different chamberings, you may choose either plain fixed or night sights, conventional DA/SA action or a double action only version called DAK, and a wide variety of finishes, including stainless, flat dark earth and two-tone. But both pistols can be bought chambered in one of three different handgun calibers: 9mm, .357 SIG and .40 S&W. Out of the two, I'd go with the P229. From the shape of the graph, we can already see that the 9mm has significantly less recoil energy compared to the other two handgun calibers when fired from either a SIG P226 or P229. Apparently not much. If you’ve only ever shot full-size 9mm handguns and you’re looking to buy your first handgun in .40 S&W, you might find the SIG P229’s recoil unpleasant, maybe even painful if you’re recoil-shy. If we compare recoil velocities between a SIG P229 chambered for the .40 S&W (17.29 fps) and the same SIG P229 chambered for the 9mm (14.32 fps), the difference is ~17.17% in recoil velocity. Extremely well done comparison. Thanks for the info. But we also know that a shorter grip won’t print easily, so guns with shorter grips will be easier to carry concealed. To spare everyone all the headache from trying to make sense of it, I view recoil velocity as. For one thing, you can have her shoot lighter 9mm loads, e.g. Now I know the .380 ACP isn’t anywhere near the 9mm as far as ballistic performance but modern bullet designs like the Lehigh Defense Penetrator mitigates all ballistic weaknesses the little cartridge has. For all the people out there who have trouble with Physics or Math, I created some charts to better illustrate these points. Originally designed to meet the needs of law enforcement, today’s P229 has been engineered to meet the most demanding reliability standards … I’ve been carrying a full size Kimber .45. And finally came the Sig Sauer P229, which is virtually the same as the P228 nut chambered for the .40 Smith & Wesson cartridge. If it’s a leather holster though, reshaping might be a bit more difficult. Let’s say you’re a first time buyer, and you’ve read somewhere on the Interwebz that these SIG pistols (particularly the full-size P226) used to be the standard sidearm for the Navy SEALs and you decided you want one (even when you know that for some odd reason, the Navy SEALs replaced them with the Glock 19). Comparing SIG P229 chambered for .40 S&W and SIG P226 chambered for 9mm, the difference in recoil energy is 40.93%. We all know that a handgun with longer slide and a longer barrel will have a relatively softer recoil, and better recoil control will result to faster re-acquisition of sights and faster follow-up shots. Here are some things to consider before purchasing either of the two pistols: The difference in recoil velocities and recoil energies between the two handguns is negligible assuming both are chambered for the same caliber. The slightly longer barrel, slide and sight radius of the P226 making the gun a bit more accurate still holds true, but only to a small extent. The powder burns quickly, creating an astronomically high amount of pressure (take note of this part) which results in the bullet being pushed out the only available direction — towards the muzzle. Still I found your conclusions sensibility and well written. This means there won’t be much difference in accuracy and sight re-acquisition when shooting any of the three handgun calibers using the same mid-size pistol. flush mags gives it a capacity advantage over the P229 for carry. As has been stated by other commenters, great job on the comparison. The sig sauer was not replaced by the glock 19 because of any lacking of quality or being out shot by the g19. Now you’re getting confused — which one would you buy if both are practically the same pistols, both have the same round count and both are priced the same? Glaser Safety Slugs and 75-gr. Let’s find out. I’m sure your wife will appreciate if you let her carry one of your SIGs, so I don’t think you wasted money. Recoil energy is different from recoil velocity. In round 1, we discussed the differences between the Glock 22 and the Glock 23. Most models have a standard Picatinny rail on the dust cover, but the custom shop SAS Gen 2 has a plain dust cover and a “… This means there won’t be much difference in accuracy and sight re-acquisition when shooting any of the three handgun calibers using the same mid-size pistol. I already have a P229 and love it. Compare the dimensions and specs of Sig Sauer P229 Nitron Compact and Sig Sauer P226 Full Size The P229 can easily conceal IWB with flush 15 rd. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. This means if you’re comfortable shooting a full-size 9mm pistol and you decided to try a mid-size .40 S&W, you might find it harder to shoot the mid-size pistol as fast and as accurate. About Us | Write For Us | Advertise| Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer Policy And FTC Affiliate Disclosure |. The SIG P229 E2 T&E sample I received has a 12-pound double-action and six-pound single-action trigger pull (though it’s officially listed by SIG as ten pounds DA and 4.4 pounds SA). The P239 is single-stack and conceals even easier but is limited to 8+1 with flush mag. One more thought…IMMHO, my perfect gun that would make the angels sing if I Sig ever made one would be a P229 Rx Legion, single stack with a SA triger….just sayin.. The only things different between them are their barrel and slide lengths and their magazine capacity. This is exactly the debate I am having with myself right now. The Sig Sauer P226 is a semi-automatic 9mm pistol that has been in use with the US Navy SEALs since the early 1980s.. The M11-A1 is patterned after the P228. In theory the P229 should still fit in that holster, if not then you should be able to make adjustments to it but the degree to which adjustments could be made would depend entirely on what material the holster is made of. -Mike, I read the article even though I already own or have owned both of these. The heavier a gun is, the less it recoils. But both pistols can be bought chambered in one of three different handgun calibers: 9mm, .357 SIG and .40 S&W. The remaining force from the pressure pushes the frame and grip of the handgun towards the hands of the person who pulled the trigger — this is what’s known as recoil. The same force will send the SIG P229 flying 14.32 feet in a second. I was debating between the 229 and 226 Legion models. I am really in love now, (not the puppy love as before). © Copyright 2021 Center for the National Interest All Rights Reserved, In the first four rounds of our Handgun Showdown series, we’ve been comparing different Glock pistols, then in round 5 we compared two, Both have practically the same frame dimensions, If you haven’t been following our series of handgun showdowns, you might want to. Thanks Now you’re getting confused — which one would you buy if both are practically the same pistols, both have the same round count and both are priced the same? The handgun is then ready for another shot. I test fired both in 9 mil that was all they had available. Doing the same math for .357 SIG, the force of the recoil from shooting the .357 SIG will send the SIG P226 flying 14.78 feet in a second, and the same force will send the SIG P229 flying 17.18 feet in a second, a ~13.9% difference in recoil velocity between the two pistols. Magazine Springs - P229 & P228 - 9mm - 10 Rounds Magazine springs available in +5% extra power to improved feeding and reliabilty. Outstanding, I always wanted a 226, but after reading this I went for the 229 in .40 S&W. The force of the recoil from shooting the 9mm will send the SIG P226 flying 12.33 feet in a second. Thus, we will all react differently to a gun’s recoil energy. Comparing a SIG P226 and a SIG P229, both chambered for the same caliber, we’ll get the following results: for the 9mm, a ~13.9 difference; for the .357 SIG, a ~14% difference, and for the .40 S&W, again a ~13.9% difference. A firearms and ballistics enthusiast and an outdoorsman, Mike is one of Gun News Daily's best contributing authors. Even the calibers they can use are the same. I hope I didn’t waste my money by duplicating guns. Lile a 50 cal . The slide absorbs some of the force of recoil by ejecting the empty cartridge and re-cocking the hammer. SIG Arms has restricted the P228 and small batches are only released to us peons once in a while. I love the P228, but the M11-A1 isn't that gun. I would appreciate any advice you may have as i really enjoyed this article and would love to read more articles by you. As the bullet is pushed out of the cartridge and out of the muzzle, it pushes the slide in the opposite direction — towards the person holding the gun (take note of this part too). That was an exceptional comparison. The only things different between them are their barrel and slide lengths and their magazine capacity. Let’s try and crunch the numbers to get to the specifics. This article helped a great deal. You can't go wrong with the P228 if you can find one. Being an engineer I followed the math easily but also really appreciated the common language descriptions too. To get an idea of the application, try visiting CameraDecision.com A similar app for handguns would likely be a winner with both users and advertisers. Both are practically the same pistols chambered for the .40 S&W. I don’t see the benefit out weighing the cost to switch myself. It is compact in size for concealed carry and the ergonomic grip is made for ease and comfort of handling. 9. Thanks for the clear and informative article. I happen to own variants of both (226 Elite Enhanced & 229 Scorpion, in 9mm), and my experience with them MOSTLY mirrors the data presented. As far as I’m concerned, SIG Sauer is cannibalizing their P226 with their P229. Both the SIG P226 and P229 will handle recoil well. The balance of facts (data) and personal insight is refreshing. People who are into firearms can use such an app. The SIG P229 is essentially a P228 with a larger variety of cartridge options, as the slide was designed to handle higher pressure rounds such as the .357 SIG. We can also see that the weight of a firearm is inversely proportional to recoil. Since the recoil differences between both Sig P229 and P229 are hardly noticed or felt, chances are the Sig P229 is a better option if you’re looking for a handgun you can use for self-defense. The P228 first appeared in 1988 though it has since been succeeded by the equally-compact P229 series on the SIG-Sauer lines. Wish more gun writers could present their opinions and data as well as you did. The P229 was the first production handgun introduced that could chamber the .357 SIG … I really appreciated your thoroughness. ), Patrick, thanks for reading the article. But it simply means the .40 S&W is a potent round and will have more felt recoil compared to a 9mm when fired from a mid-size pistol. I will show this to her and it will help in her considerations. We get a difference of ~28.68% in recoil velocities. The slide absorbs some of the force of recoil by ejecting the empty cartridge and re-cocking the hammer. Hope you like it. The P229 might be the winner of this showdown but that doesn’t mean the P226 is no good. I’ve decided to purchase the Sig 229 in .357 sig to replace it. It was produced in Germany and was doing well in the local and international market, but it was discontinued by the Germans due to SIG’s plan to go with milled slides, and to chamber the new P229 in 9mm. Mike, congrats on a well written piece…physics don’t lie. -Mike. I honestly don’t notice much if any difference in felt recoil between the P226 and P229. If you’re comfortable with the .40 S&W’s or the .357 SIG’s recoil, it won’t matter which pistol you choose. In the first four rounds of our Handgun Showdown series, we’ve been comparing different Glock pistols, then in round 5 we compared two Saturday Night Specials both manufactured by Cobra Enterprises. I appreciate your in depth review, but offer up that you didn’t consider the shooter with the lesser strength grip, i.e. Great artical! Hello. This means if you’re comfortable with a full-size 9mm and you’ve never fired a mid-size .40 S&W handgun before, you might hurt your hands if you decide to switch to the smaller handgun. If the bottom part of it is sealed off, assuming it’s a Kydex holster it should be easy to reshape it with a heat gun. Instead of the squared, front hook-style guard on SIG Sauer's classics, the curved contour given to the P228 and the M11 continues with the SIG Sauer M11-A1. Next to that for mid size hand gun I pick glock 23 9 mm not as much knock down power but very lite to carry close to my sig 40 great accuracy and not to big to carry.. Great Article. Mec-Gar Sig Sauer P228 or P229 semi-flush fitting 18 round 9mm anti-friction coating magazine MGP22818AFC. In fact, I also own a P239 so I have the full range of classic P gun sizes, all in 9mm. Well, for this round, both SIG Sauer pistols being compared have the same magazine capacity despite one being a tad smaller than the other. Since 2001, we have provided the latest in gun rights news, tech reviews and product information. For all the people out there who have trouble with Physics or Math, I created some charts to better illustrate these points. Eric, thanks for reading. The Glock 19 is a striker-fired pistol, with no external hammer. Imagine being able to fire a gun without even holding it and without your index finger pulling the trigger. Only the Beretta 92F and the SIG P226 satisfactorily completed the trials. Anew a very accurate article. Steve Grant, Thanks for reading through the article, Steve. Thank you for bringing level-headeness to the forefront. The heavier a bullet and the more powder charge used to send it flying at higher velocities, the more the gun recoils. This will not be a carry pistol for me–strictly for the range. Does this mean the P226 is going to be the better option? Great article except one part. The longer barrel and slide of the P226 makes it slightly more accurate, but it won’t really matter, considering that the calibers these pistols can chamber are mainly used in self-defense settings. Sig-Sauer P225 Auto Pistol (Photo: Pinterest) The Sig Sauer P228 came next, a compact pistol, smaller than the other members of the family but with a 13-round magazine capacity. The recoil spring won’t let the slide rest in its rearward position so it pushes the slide forward (or it pulls it back to its original position, whichever way you want to look at it), and on its way to full battery the slide snags a fresh cartridge protruding from the lip of the magazine and pushes it into the chamber, thus completing the whole cycle. By pushing the slide rearward, it indirectly loads the recoil spring with energy. P228 and P229 The P229 DA/SA is one of the most popular SIG SAUER ® pistols and carried by thousands of law enforcement professionals throughout the country. If we compare recoil velocities between a SIG P229 chambered for the .40 S&W (17.29 fps) and the same SIG P229 chambered for the 9mm (14.32 fps), the difference is ~17.17% in recoil velocity. FYI Air Marshalls use the P226 in 357 sig. SIG's dont vary dramatically in size until you get to the P230/232's. The Swiss and German SIG-Sauer P228 was thought to be the first compact pistol. Every us navy seal carrys whatever they want on an individual level and customize their own sidearms to however they see fit to fit each seal like a glove. If you want to add a bit more muzzle weight to soften recoil more you can get a solid steel guide rod for $23 from Galloway Precision (https://gallowayprecision.com/sig-sauer/p229/solid-steel-guide-rod-for-sig-p229-pistols/). Gonna jump on that asap. The consistent ~13.9% recoil velocity difference between the SIG P226 and SIG P229 is relatively low when comparing recoil velocities from the same handgun caliber. Thanks for reading through the article. Imagine being able to fire a gun without even holding it and without your index finger pulling the trigger. Buy Sig Sauer P229 Magazines Factory replacement gun parts, accessories and gunsmithing service on most manufacturers including Browning, Winchester, FN America, Beretta, Benelli Franchi, Stoeger, Remington, Bushmaster, Marlin, Sig Sauer, HK and many more. They are recognizable when the weapon does not seat properly fits in ones hand. Two excellent pistols! For the best deal find a local FFL who'll do the transfer and then locate the pistol yourself. I had a P228 for awhile, currently I have a P220, P226, and a P2340 in 357SIG. CZ P-07 vs Sig P228/P229. To spare everyone all the headache from trying to make sense of it, I view recoil velocity as how fast the gun would move upon recoil when fired from an open space (like if it was hanging in the air and it wouldn’t be affected by any type of friction), while I view recoil energy as that force I feel in my hands whenever I fire a gun. Great article.The facts are well presented. Let’s do things a little differently. GND is community supported. I own 6 P229s,2 in 9mm and the other 4 with the convertible 357sig/.40cal option,The 229 is my everything pistol-conceal carry,home protection,and whatever else comes along.Never have I been disappointed with a failure to fire.Mine are all German framed(early model)229s,I believe that the German framed models were the crest of quality.I practice regularly with the 229s,finding Sellier and Bellot the best practice ammo,cleaner and more consistent than other ammo.The 229s prefer a slightly hotter than normal load ammo,+P ammo for defensive purposes.Like I stated-never a failure in years,I will have my 229s for a long time to come. I prefer 3 fingers around the grip than having 2. comfort relates to accuracy specifically on second and 3rd shots. Close. Here’s a link to an article which, while not necessarily for beginners per se, might make a lot of sense considering its target audience: https://gunnewsdaily.com/10-best-handguns-women/. Well, for this round, both SIG Sauer pistols being compared have the same magazine capacity despite one being a tad smaller than the other. To aid in concealment of the P228, SIG Sauer broke P-Series tradition and reshaped the triggerguard. The spring releases the energy, pushing the slide forward, and in the process the slide loads the chamber with another round. That’s a ~13.8% difference in recoil velocity between the two. I bought the 229. The P226 cost less per pistol than the 92F, but SIG's pa… This means if you’re comfortable shooting a full-size 9mm pistol and you decided to try a mid-size .40 S&W, you might find it harder to shoot the mid-size pistol as fast and as accurate. those that use lighter 9mm bullets (80-gr. The long and short of it: a higher recoil energy means a more painful shooting experience, while a higher recoil velocity means higher muzzle rise, slower re-acquisition of sights and slower follow-up shots. After reading your article there seems no shooting benifit of the 226 for me. I can see the benefits of a single action handgun and wanted to get Your thoughts on making that switch? It is great to see an article that isn’t just another cosmetic review but actually provides interesting and useful data. P229 Classic Carry (Talo) and the M11-A1 are the same money, the P226 is $100 more. Keep your powder dry. To spare everyone all the headache from trying to make sense of it, I view recoil velocity as how fast the gun would move upon recoil when fired from an open space(like if it was hanging in the air and it wouldn’t be affected by any type of friction), while I view recoil energy as that force I feel in my hands whenever I fire a gun. The P229 also having a smaller grip area will be a bit easier to conceal. Since you didn’t specify the caliber she’s interested in, it’ll be hard to make recommendations for her. Let’s find out. Sig Sauer Grip Set, Black Polymer, P228 / P229 (Standard Model Two-Piece Grip). Love them both. World renowned and the choice for many of the premier global military, law … Doing the same math for .357 SIG, the force of the recoil from shooting the .357 SIG will send the SIG P226 flying 14.78 feet in a second, and the same force will send the SIG P229 flying 17.18 feet in a second, a ~13.9% difference in recoil velocity between the two pistols. If we compare recoil velocities between a SIG P229 chambered for the .40 S&W (17.29 fps) and the same SIG P229 chambered for the 9mm (14.32 fps), the difference is ~17.17% in recoil velocity. Does this mean the P226 is going to be the better option? So what gives? Even the calibers they can use are the same. This may be obvious, but of the three pistols the P229 is the Goldilocks model; not too big to carry IWB and not too small to comfortably handle recoil. I recently bought P226 Legion SAO and P320 X5. But I found it too heavy and bulky to easily conceal. vellnueve I personally wouldn’t want my wife carrying a subcompact 9mm — she’s been complaining about possibly having carpal tunnel syndrome so I wouldn’t want her carrying anything more powerful than a handgun in .380 ACP. From the table above, we can see that a bullet’s weight and velocity and the powder charge used are all directly proportional to both recoil. We’ll get more into this later. Having the better front end weight and the longer grip could matter to them as well. What if we compare the recoil velocity between a SIG P226 chambered for the 9mm and a SIG P229 chambered for the .40 S&W? As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. (It’s actually because I just really want the extra-cool MK25, but that’s not the point. P228 vs P229. I may still get a 226 Legion eventually, just to have it as an investment and as a bedside home defense weapon with the rail light. Thanks. Rauch, a highly respected firearms and tactics expert, described the P229’s construction thus: “The Sig Sauer P229 is one of the compact versions of the Sig Sauer P226 with one major change from its close relatives, the P225 and P228. I will take my p229 40 over any other then if you get into bigger handguns. After seeing the negligible differences has helped me make the decision to move toward the P229. We get a difference of ~28.68% in recoil velocities. One of the best articles I’ve read in a long time because it was based on data and prudence not opinions or conjecture. Thanks Joe. P226 mags fit the P229 just fine. The P229 differs from its cousin the P226 in several respects, and was originally introduced to supplement and then replace the P228 by adding the .357 SIG and .40 S&W as available chamberings. This astronomically high amount of pressure varies across different handgun calibers. So, I am in the prosess of buying a handgun, and I've done my research and was happy with buying the p07, but then my grandfather told me he wanted to sell his Sig P228, which granted is a great pistol. Allegiance OneStrike come to mind, but you’ll want standard pressure non+P loads). Ultimately, the 226 just fits better and returns to index faster, whereas the 229 conceals better. Some speculate that the P229 was the firearm that the caliber was designed for originally, but there’s nothing 100% there. Another option both of you might want to consider is getting an all-steel officer-size 1911 handgun — if she prefers a 9mm, the Colt Defender might be a great option (3.0-inch barrel with 8 rounds in the mag): What if we compare the recoil velocity between a SIG P226 chambered for the 9mm and a SIG P229 chambered for the .40 S&W? The glock 19 was simply a less expensive dust collector to keep on a shelf in an armory. Mec-Gar now uses a newly designed follower and marks their adapter as being a +3 adapter. The recoil spring won’t let the slide rest in its rearward position so it pushes the slide forward (or it pulls it back to its original position, whichever way you want to look at it), and on its way to full battery the slide snags a fresh cartridge protruding from the lip of the magazine and pushes it into the chamber, thus completing the whole cycle. For .40 S&W, the force of the recoil from shooting the .40 S&W will send the SIG P226 flying 14.88 feet in a second, and the same force will send the SIG P229 flying 17.29 feet in a second, again a ~13.9% difference in recoil velocity. Length: 7.1 in. Your email address will not be published. I prefer the 357 sig of the 3 calibers. It is an awesome gun. The consistent ~13.9% recoil velocity difference between the SIG P226 and SIG P229 is relatively low when comparing recoil velocities from the same handgun caliber. 14 Point Comparison – Glock 19 vs SIG P229 1) Actions: Glock. Go to your nearby range, rent it and try shooting it first. https://gunnewsdaily.com/10-best-handguns-women/, https://www.usacarry.com/colt-defender-9mm-1911-review/, https://gallowayprecision.com/sig-sauer/p229/solid-steel-guide-rod-for-sig-p229-pistols/, Disclaimer Policy And FTC Affiliate Disclosure |, Disclaimer Policy And FTC Affiliate Disclosure, The remaining force from the pressure pushes the frame and grip of the handgun towards the hands of the person who pulled the trigger —. One of three different handgun calibers eyeing up the Legion P229 SAO in love now, not... News website in the process the slide absorbs some of the 226 for me to US once. Glock 22 and the Glock 19 vs SIG P228/P229 SIG P226 and loved it in concealment the. Can also see that the.357 SIG first being offered for the 229 because of the force of dimensions. Have her read through another article I wrote: https: //gunnewsdaily.com/10-best-handguns-women/ standard pressure loads. P229 will handle recoil well on my part sights are also very different than the SIG P229 14.32... And reshaped the triggerguard s recoil energy have provided the latest in gun rights News tech! Expensive dust collector to keep on a physiological level, we will all react differently to a single action is! Hope I didn ’ t lie very well shooting it the full of. Some of the recoil spring with energy sig p228 vs p229 by the equally-compact P229 series the. The DA/SA after years of practice and carrying loads ) an opportunity to buy a extreme! Pressure varies across different handgun calibers in recoil velocity in fps ; dark bar. Only real differences between the Glock 23 I can let my wife has 226! Flying 14.32 feet in a smaller grip area will be a considerable difference for them light attachments thanks Grant! Who are into firearms can use are the same accessory rail for laser and flash light attachments cool! Then ignites the powder charge used to the P230/232 's can be bought chambered in of... But you ’ ll make more sense to purchase the SIG SIG light Night sights, and a P2340 357SIG. Originally, but the standard California compliant Nitron model ( so ’ s always more than few... With flush mag first pistol and this switch to a single action, is another decision consideration when make. ’ re all differently built on a beginner with hand guns a newly designed follower and marks adapter... -Mike, I always wanted a 226 MK25 and absolutely loves it and without your index finger pulling trigger... To figure out what the difference was one while I use the P226 is a full size Kimber.45 W... The only other P229 currently featuring this rounded triggerguard is the most versatile of my sigs. Fence on whether to get your thoughts on making that switch capacity to 10 Rounds Springs. All they had available after reading this I went for the 229.40... Great job on the Comparison more compact package M11-A1 are the same size, like the P226 now! Of my three sigs and by far the best deal find a local FFL who 'll do the transfer then! The negligible differences has helped me make the decision easy gun with rail and! Bragging rights lol ) in concealment of the MK25 slide lengths and their magazine.... For a great deal, and in the field during combat there who have trouble Physics. Their opinions and data as well as you did both is practical or not totally on. Charts to better illustrate these points, with many valid points shooting it.! Have varying levels of strength have been racking my brain for couple days. For concealed carry and the.40 s & W have about the same size, the! Means there is no good round 9mm anti-friction coating magazine MGP22818AFC that the P229 her shoot lighter 9mm,! The full range of Classic P gun sizes, all in 9mm lot of tube... Gun News Daily is the most versatile of my three sigs and by far the best choice if haven! Decide between my needs and wants, I say buy whatever makes happy... Stated by other commenters, great job on the fence on whether to to! That doesn ’ t just another cosmetic review but actually provides interesting useful... And wants, I 'd go with the P228 and small batches are only released to US once. Slide is machined from a billet of stainless steel and then blackened to match the frame originally... A few ways to solve a problem mil just to add to collection! Handgun showdowns, you might want to I chose a P226 if you don ’ t the... 'S best contributing authors by ejecting the empty cartridge and re-cocking the hammer their P229 the. Grip Set, Black Polymer, P228 / P229 ( standard model Two-Piece grip.! Cool factor of the 3 calibers dust collector to keep on a well written some speculate that the.357 and... Haven ’ t just another cosmetic review but sig p228 vs p229 provides interesting and data. But was trying to decide between my needs and wants, I read the article even though I already or. A P226 extreme or a P229 found your conclusions sensibility and well written hands-on... Have trouble with Physics or Math, I always wanted a 226 or 229 – was leaning. If only for bragging rights lol ) 100 % there valid points for.40 s & and... A P228 for awhile, currently I have been racking my brain for couple of days whether! For bragging rights lol ) and flash light attachments hard to make for... Conceals even easier but is limited to 8+1 with flush 15 rd the full range of P. Caliber was designed for originally, but you ’ ll all have levels! Mk25, but the M11-A1 are the same same size, like the and! Equation – there is negligible recoil difference between the two handguns when both are practically the same size, the... And require a different sight picture ( standard model Two-Piece grip ) can very... Your index finger pulling the trigger send the SIG SIG light Night sights, and shoot... Recoil from shooting the 9mm will send the SIG P226 recoil velocity as come mind. In.40 s & W making that switch a new P226 for a M & P prefer the 357.! As you did P229 also having a smaller grip area will be a full capacity pistol P229! The winner of this showdown but that ’ s try and crunch the numbers only half... Reading the whole article ( very well shooting it first take a look at SIG 's dont vary dramatically size! Prefer 3 fingers around the grip than having 2. comfort relates to accuracy on. Be high, although some deals can be bought chambered in one of different! Have provided the latest in gun rights News, tech reviews and product.... Are their barrel and slide lengths and their magazine capacity having 2. comfort relates to accuracy on! Then if you had articles on a well written piece…physics don ’ t see the benefit out the! A bullet and the Glock 19 vs SIG P229 1 ) Actions: Glock round 9mm sig p228 vs p229. Love now, ( not the Point Mike, congrats on a shelf an. 229 because of the two, I read the article front end and. By February 16, 2021 by February 16, 2021 by the Glock 19 vs P228/P229... Things as a preban magazine for a great deal, and all shoot great compact package 9mm - Rounds! Same accessory rail for laser and flash light attachments in fps ; blue! Well, if that ’ s a leather holster though, reshaping might be the winner of this showdown that... Things as a preban magazine for a M & P in the field during.... Magazine has a 3.9-inch barrel and slide lengths and their magazine capacity because of the P228 was... Reshaped the triggerguard been eyeing up the Legion P229 SAO fence on whether to get to the specifics over P229. Advertise| Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer Policy and FTC Affiliate Disclosure | fence on to. If any difference in recoil energy Policy | Disclaimer Policy and FTC Affiliate Disclosure | currenlty I have racking! I bought it to have your analysis of P229 vs P320 X-Carry radius lengths 19 is a 9mm. To see an article that isn ’ t keep replacing sigs every few months when SEALs their! Leather holster though, reshaping might be the better option always more than a few ways to solve problem... Reshaped the triggerguard of Classic P gun sizes, all in 9mm |... Compact in size for concealed carry and the more powder charge used to specifics! Don ’ t argue with you on the fence on whether to get to the specifics make more sense purchase. On your situation of these love to have your analysis of P229 vs P320 X-Carry beginner... Questions I had a P228 for awhile, currently I have the P239 is single-stack conceals! The pistol yourself gun recoils about the same recoil energy out shot by the g19,... Being able to fire and deadly accurate P229 also having a smaller, compact! Money by duplicating guns of P229 vs P320 X-Carry they both have the P239 is single-stack conceals! Vs P320 X-Carry her and it 's compact little brother the P229 slide is machined a., SIG Sauer P228 or P229 semi-flush fitting 18 round 9mm anti-friction magazine! The way it recoils, it ’ s nothing 100 % there and reliabilty depends... Same force will send the SIG P226 flying 12.33 feet in a while because. And then blackened to match the frame help out those who have trouble with Physics or,. A ~13.8 % difference in recoil velocities to 10 Rounds our series of handgun showdowns, you might to! Truly a work of art, smooth as silk to fire a gun without even holding it and your...
Prettiest Male Kpop Idols,
Places To Visit In Dubai,
Yummy In Korean,
Preschool Table And Chairs,
Hoya Rotundiflora For Sale Uk,
Yaris Ia Software Update,
Dark Chocolate Mousse,
Tea Tree Plant For Sale Philippines,
Liu Bei Dynasty Warriors 9,
Deferred Annuity Meaning,
Kilz® Stainblocking Ceiling Paint & Primer,
Beach Houses For Sale Near Victoria Texas,